How to value a business with no revenue

A business with no revenue is valued on what lowers an investor's risk: the idea, the team, a working prototype, early relationships and the size of the market. The Berkus and Scorecard methods turn those judgements into a figure. Because they are judgements, the honest answer is a range you can explain, not one number.

Can a business with no revenue have a valuation?

Yes. Before revenue, a valuation is a price that you and an investor agree on. It is not a measurement of sales or profit, because there are none yet.

The price decides how much of the business an investor gets. Here is an example with invented numbers. You and an investor agree the business is worth ₹4 crore before the investment. The investor puts in ₹1 crore. The business is now worth ₹5 crore, and the investor owns ₹1 crore out of ₹5 crore, which is 20%.

The ₹4 crore is the pre-money valuation and the ₹5 crore is the post-money valuation. The methods below are ways to reach the first figure and explain it.

Which valuation methods work before revenue?

Methods that score risk and compare your business with others work before revenue. Methods built on forecast profits do not, because the forecast is mostly guesswork.

MethodHow it reaches a figureWhat you need
Berkus methodAdds an amount for each of five things that lower riskAn honest view of how far each one has come
Scorecard methodStarts from what similar businesses were valued at, then adjusts up or downA typical valuation for businesses like yours in your region
Comparable dealsLooks at what investors paid for similar businessesDetails of recent deals, which are often private
Venture capital methodWorks back from what the business could be worth later and the return the investor needsA view of the future size of the business

Investors themselves rely little on forecast-based methods early on. In a survey of almost 900 venture capitalists by Gompers, Gornall, Kaplan and Strebulaev (Journal of Financial Economics, 2020), few used discounted cash flow, and 20% said they do not forecast cash flows at all when they invest.

How does the Berkus method work?

The Berkus method adds up to a fixed amount for each of five things a young business may have. Angel investor Dave Berkus created it in the mid-1990s, and it was first published widely in 2001 in the book Winning Angels.

In his own version, each element can add up to US$500,000.

If the business hasIt lowersAdds up to
A sound ideaThe risk that there is no basic valueUS$500,000
A prototypeTechnology riskUS$500,000
A quality management teamExecution riskUS$500,000
Strategic relationshipsMarket riskUS$500,000
Product rollout or salesProduction riskUS$500,000

That gives a ceiling of US$2 million before revenue and US$2.5 million once the product is rolled out. Berkus calls these figures maximums and has said they should be adjusted for where the business is based. He also says the method assumes a business that could pass US$20 million in revenue by its fifth year. So do not simply convert the dollar amounts into rupees or dirhams.

A worked example, with invented numbers. Suppose an investor in your market sets the ceiling for each element at ₹1 crore.

ElementYour positionAmount given
Sound ideaA clear problem, checked with customers₹60 lakh
PrototypeWorks, but not finished₹50 lakh
Management teamTwo founders with industry experience₹80 lakh
Strategic relationshipsOne signed pilot₹30 lakh
Product rollout or salesNone yet₹0
Total₹2.2 crore

How does the Scorecard method work?

The Scorecard method starts from the typical valuation of similar businesses and moves it up or down by comparing yours with them. Angel investor Bill Payne wrote it up in 2001 and has revised it since. The Angel Capital Association publishes his 2019 revision.

  1. Find the median pre-money valuation of pre-revenue businesses in your region and sector.
  2. Compare your business with those on seven factors. Each factor has a maximum weight.
  3. Add up the results and multiply by the median.

A worked example, with invented numbers. Suppose the median in step one is ₹5 crore. A rating of 100% means "the same as a typical business".

FactorMaximum weightYour ratingResult
Strength of the management team30%125%0.375
Size of the opportunity25%100%0.250
Product or technology15%100%0.150
Competitive environment10%75%0.075
Marketing, sales channels and partnerships10%80%0.080
Need for additional investment5%100%0.050
Other5%100%0.050
Total1.030

₹5 crore multiplied by 1.03 gives ₹5.15 crore.

The hard part is step one. We have not found a published median for India or the Gulf that we can vouch for, so we do not quote one. Ask a valuation expert, or investors you trust, what businesses like yours have recently been valued at.

Why is a range more honest than a single number?

A range is more honest because every input above is a judgement, and two fair people will judge differently.

Take the Scorecard example. You rated your team at 125%. An investor may rate the same team at 100%. That one change moves the total from 1.03 to 0.955, and the figure from ₹5.15 crore to about ₹4.8 crore. Neither is wrong.

A range also gives you a floor and a ceiling to negotiate between.

What raises or lowers a pre-revenue valuation?

A valuation rises with proof and falls with open risks. Both methods weigh the same kinds of things.

Raises itLowers it
Founders with experience in the industry, working full-timeGaps in the team with no plan to fill them
A working prototypeAn idea on paper only
Signed pilots, letters of intent or first usersNo contact with customers yet
A large market, with your working shownA market figure with nothing behind it
Enough money from this round to reach the next proof pointNeeding much more money soon

One thing is outside your control: what similar businesses in your region are being valued at.

How will investors check your number?

Investors check a pre-revenue number by testing your reasoning and comparing it with other deals they have seen. Expect four questions.

  1. How did you get this? Show the method, your inputs and the range on one page.
  2. Compared with what? They will set your figure beside businesses like yours.
  3. What must this become? In the survey above, the measure venture capitalists used most was the multiple of their money they expect back. Your figure has to leave room for that.
  4. What share do I get? Your valuation and your ask together decide it. See how much equity to give an investor.

What investors look for covers the rest of what they check.

Do you need a valuation if you are not raising yet?

No, but a working range is useful before you raise. It shows which proof would move the figure most, and it prepares you for the day a partner or an investor asks what the business is worth.

A working range is not a formal valuation report. If a tax authority, a regulator or a bank asks for a report, ask a qualified professional in your country.

AI estimate or valuation expert: when should you use each?

Use an AI estimate to get a first range quickly and to see what drives it. Use a valuation expert when the number will be tested by someone else.

Use an AI estimate whenUse a valuation expert when
You want a starting range todayYou are about to negotiate with an investor
You are comparing "what if" casesYour inputs are unusual or hard to compare
You are not raising yetYou want a person to check the assumptions

How does RightPitch help with a valuation?

On RightPitch, Nia, the AI assistant, builds a valuation range from your own details, with its reasoning, alongside your pitch deck. You can then hire a verified valuation expert, paid per engagement, to check the range and its assumptions. It is free to start, and you do not have to be raising money. See startup valuation and verified experts.

Questions

What is a pre-revenue startup valuation?

It is the price put on a business that has not yet made sales, agreed between the founder and an investor. It rests on the team, the idea, any prototype, early relationships and the size of the market, and is best given as a range.

How do you value a business idea?

An idea alone sits at the bottom of any range, because nothing has yet lowered the risk. In the Berkus method, a sound idea is one of five elements. The figure rises as you add a prototype, a team, relationships and first sales.

What is the Berkus method?

The Berkus method values a young business by adding an amount for each of five elements: a sound idea, a prototype, a quality management team, strategic relationships, and product rollout or sales. In Dave Berkus's own version each adds up to US$500,000. These are maximums, to be adjusted by region.

What is the Scorecard valuation method?

The Scorecard method, written up by Bill Payne, starts from the median valuation of similar pre-revenue businesses in your region. It then adjusts that figure on seven weighted factors, with the management team weighted highest at up to 30%.

How do you value an early-stage startup?

Use more than one method and compare the results. Score the business with the Berkus and Scorecard methods, check the figures against what similar businesses were valued at, and present a range with your reasoning.

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules, schemes and figures change. The sources above were last checked on ; confirm anything you rely on with a qualified adviser.

Become investor-ready